Brett Favre a Top 5 QB Ever? (2025)

Richard said:

Point on Namath but his influence on the game was, and is, still being felt.

Bradshaw is underrated. 4 Super Bowls - the first two he was more of a systems QB but the dirty secret is that the Steelers defense was OLD in 78 and 79 and the Steelers won because of their offense, specifically Bradshaw.

Dude threw the ball like it was a dart. Proof you didn't actually watch him.

Click to expand...

Im 56, I watched every last playoff game since 1975

He had 2 HOF WR's and a HOF RB. He was amazing in 1978, but he had more weapons than anyone until maybe the Rams skill position players.

Quid Pro Clowe said:

Young beat the Cowboys, he couldn’t beat Favre and the Pack.

Just as Rodgers can’t beat SF and any random qb they start in the playoffs.

Click to expand...

Which was mostly due to that imbecile McCarthy.

Richard said:

Favre is the most overrated QB in NFL history. He is more Vinny Testaverde than Tom Brady.

Btw, Dan Marino was the best QB in NFL history.....

Click to expand...

What a God awful take.

Voight said:

What a God awful take.

Click to expand...

Yeah there's far more overrated than him as much as i'd love to clown on Favre for being a POS. Eli Manning, Troy Aikman, John Elway.

Favre's stretch from 1995-1997 is legitimately one of the best stretches for a QB in history.

Blitzkrug said:

Yeah there's far more overrated than him as much as i'd love to clown on Favre for being a POS. Eli Manning, Troy Aikman, John Elway.

Favre's stretch from 1995-1997 is legitimately one of the best stretches for a QB in history.

Click to expand...

i think manning is properly rated for the most part. a fairly unimpressive career outside of two SB titles

won't argue over aikman or elway though

Voight said:

What a God awful take.

Click to expand...

To be fair, by definition of "most overrated in history", this should be most peoples' response. If you agreed with him, he wouldn't be overrated.

...It's a shame this disease is going to hinder his ability to steal poor people's money.

Nogatco Rd said:

Him and Chad Kelly are both cut from the same cloth. Hard to have any respect or admiration for POS sexual harassers who got team employees fired for turning down their advances.

Click to expand...

Chad Kelly's advances were not turned down, and she wasn't fired.

keonsbitterness said:

Chad Kelly's advances were not turned down, and she wasn't fired.

Click to expand...

So then why was he suspended?

Per the lawsuit, Kelly allegedly became “very adamant” about “hanging out” away from work during the 2023 season. Kelly “visibly got mad and aggravated” when she declined.

The plaintiff also alleges that Kelly planned dates for them, but that she consistently refused. At one point, Kelly allegedly said they would need only 30 minutes for a date.

The lawsuit alleges that, when she tried to address the situation, Kelly said he “cannot wait” until she’s fired. She eventually was, and she’s now suing.

According to the summary, investigators concluded Kelly did make persistent advances on the former coach, which constitute “sexual harassment as defined by the Ontario Occupational Health and Safety Act.”

Among the evidence supporting the finding of sexual harassment are copies of text messages from Kelly to the former coach in September of 2023, including one in which Kelly invites her to his hotel room in Hamilton, one in which Kelly asks her over to his place, and another in which she tells another Argos employee of the persistent invitations from Kelly.

The executive summary also supports two other allegations – that Kelly acted aggressively towards the former coach when confronted in the team breakfast room on the morning of Nov. 6, 2023, and that later that same day Kelly yelled derogatory words at the former coach.

Nogatco Rd said:

So then why was he suspended?

Click to expand...

Because he verbally went off in public (bad move) after they stopped dating.

Brady
P. Manning
Rodgers
Montana
Mahomes

All better than Favre.

Not top 5. But probably close.

keonsbitterness said:

Because he verbally went off in public (bad move) after they stopped dating.

Click to expand...

Do you have a source for the claim that they were dating? Because if so then Chad Kelly perjured himself in his sworn statement when he said he never had any romantic relationship with her.

Nogatco Rd said:

Do you have a source for the claim that they were dating? Because if so then Chad Kelly perjured himself in his sworn statement when he said he never had any romantic relationship with her.

Click to expand...

Doesn't matter now. She settled and both parties can't say anything.

This story has a lot of layers that would sound like crazy gossip if I posted what I was told, which I won't.

keonsbitterness said:

Doesn't matter now. She settled and both parties can't say anything.

This story has a lot of layers that would sound like crazy gossip if I posted what I was told, which I won't.

Click to expand...

Lmao so both Kelly and his accuser say she was fired.. yet you claim she wasn’t

They both swore under oath that they weren’t in a relationship.. yet you claim they were

Don’t really care to continue the derail since this isn’t the Chad Kelly POS behavior thread…